Thursday, December 15, 2011

Wicked Wikipedia?



Wikipedia (to most librarians) is the devil. We spend hours teaching students how to evaluate information sources, how to disseminate what is worthy information apart from the gobs of goo out there on the WWW. We teach students over and over again that databases are the most reliable electronic resources for solid information, and are dismayed when some simple Googling is necessary that the first results (ugh) in a search list include Wikipedia. Ew. I have spent many hours of my life explaining why we must FLEE from this evil, Wicked Wikipedia.

Here's the deal...Wikipedia entries can be edited by anyone. ANYONE. Quickly. With fact-checking completed only by others who read and edit the article. This is dangerous. I use the example of  myself as an editor of the entry on algebraic equations as an example to illustrate the dangers of such practice. (Those who know me well will get this.) Bottom line: people who are far from experts are passing themselves off as such when they edit a Wikipedia entry. In the criteria for evaluating information, this would be called a major risk of authenticity. For me, (working with little, impressionable minds), it is not worth that risk. I want to fill their noggins with good, proven, tried and true, accurate information...not "Eh, maybe it's right."


But there's no doubt about it...Wikipedia isn't going anywhere. It is a piece of the information pie at which students are chomping away every stinkin' day; so, using this example of the To Kill a Mockingbird entry, let's consider for a moment a few ways Wikipedia can be used effectively when teaching information literacy.

  • First off, each entry is structured with a Table of Contents. That's a handy reference skill every student needs to master, most especially when utilizing digital resources. 
  • The various elements listed in the Table of Contents can be thought-provoking for students as well. This list could be of assistance to a student attempting to determine their three points for an essay on the novel. 



  •  The "See also" section in each entry provides links to other Wikipedia entries related to this particular topic. Again, though researchers should think long and hard about citing Wikipedia, the tool itself can be helpful in providing some varying or even deeper points of view regarding a particular topic or issue. 



  • The "Notes," "References," and "Bibliography" section toward the bottom is supposed to provide citations or further research for the work included in the entry (again, by various Joes from Anyplace, USA). The links quite possible could be reliable information, but then again, it is Wikipedia...who's fact-checking?





  • "External links" is most commonly where students can find the gold Wikipedia has to offer. Non-wiki links are provided here which, hopefully (but not assuredly) verify the information within the entry. Students should not cite Wikipedia, but should consider these external links as potential sources for solid information. 



  • This feature allows the article to be read to the student. This is a tool becoming fairly common on most websites, and is of great use to assisting students with exceptional learning needs or even English deficiencies. 


There you have it. What say you? Are you teaching your students to FLEE from the perils of Wicked Wikipedia, or are you allowing them to use the source within certain contexts?

For more info on the use of Wikipedia in the academic realm:

http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2007/01/26/wiki

http://library.williams.edu/citing/wikipedia.php

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not

http://chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/wikipedia-founder-discourages-academic-use-of-his-creation/2305

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20071101/042649.shtml

27 comments:

  1. I also use Wikipedia to teach my students how to locate, use and properly cite high-quality images. Wikipedia is a treasure trove for images. It helps me explain what is wrong with using Google images for academic work.

    Finally, I tell my students that it is ok to begin with Wikepedia as a way to get off the starting block with research. As with any encyclopedia, however, it is not to be cited or used as a source for notes. Background information, images and external links are Wikipedia's gold.

    Mary Kay Risi
    Teacher-Librarian
    River Dell Middle School
    River Edge, NJ

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you are going to talk about Wikipedia and librarians, you can't leave out the ALA's use, rather misuse, of Wikipedia. I have been banned from Wikipedia thanks to the ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom for publishing on my own blog about the ALA's misuse of Wikipedia, and I have been told that I may not return to Wikipedia until I censor out the following:

    "ALA Pushes Net Neutrality on Wikipedia; Political and Pecuniary Interests Promoted Anonymously by ALA Office for Intellectual Freedom May Violate Ethical and Tax Codes," by Dan Kleinman, SafeLibraries, 20 December 2010.

    In summary, it's not Wikipedia that's wicked.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mary Kay, that is a fantastic way to utilize Wikipedia. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

    SafeLibraries, thank you for your comment. This has been a wonderful discussion and eye-opening for many on both sides of the spectrum: those who think Wikipedia is an acceptable source for information and those who doubt all pieces of Wikipedia's credibility. I think through our discussion on the AASL forum we have learned that Wikipedia isn't wicked at all...so long as we do our jobs in teaching responsible use.

    ReplyDelete
  4. *Posting comment below on behalf of Meg Brooke.

    Since I can't respond to "comments" I'll respond here. What perfect timing! We have a class in 10 minutes on credibility in websites! Thanks for more insight on wikipedia!

    Two years ago when I was getting ready to do a class on this subject I was flipping through the mail and found our NY Times Upfront supplement which we get once a year. It had an article, The Perils of Wikipedia, which told the true story of a sociology student at the Univ. College Dublin in Ireland who did an experiment intentionally putting false info in Wikipedia about a French composer who had recently died. Amazing to him, the Associated Press used Wikipedia and published it without digging for its veracity! What a great example to be able to use for the class!

    Most of our teachers don't allow students to use it in their bibliographies as references, but we see it on MANY screens! It'll probably always be a battle for research purposes....

    On the other hand.....I do use it as a quick reference many times to just "see" what something is. If I want really good facts, though, I do go digging! :-)
    Thanks for the post!


    Meg Brooke,NBCT
    LMS
    Shades Valley HS/Jefferson County International Baccalaureate School

    ReplyDelete
  5. Healrun is a health news blog we provide the latest news about health, Drugs and latest Diseases and conditions. We update our users with health tips and health products reviews. If you want to know any information about health or health product (Side Effects & Benefits) Feel Free To ask HealRun Support Team.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tevida There are usually two primary reasons for men to suffer from the problem of low sex drive. The first reason is genetics; if this problem runs in the family then there are chances that you too will be facing the same issues and will have to just handle them to the extent that you can. The second and more common reason these days, which has come up to ruin men's sexual drives is that of a poor lifestyle. Men who have erratic lifestyles with no proper sleep



    https://fitose.com/tevida-testosterone-booster/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Slim Quick Keto o The weight loss program you choose should ultimately teach you how to eat and be self reliant so you can make informed long term choices about your nutrition.



    https://fitose.com/slim-quick-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Mira essence cream No joke! You can find day and night creams which offer all of that in one cream! Most are going by the term "day cream" and "night cream." Usually, if there are two different creams the night version is intended to keep the healing and nourishing aspects going around the clock. The ingredients will vary slightly and they will be made to complement one another perfectly.


    https://fitose.com/mira-essence-cream-canada/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Keto burn xtreme review "The results suggest that psychological factors may provide some explanation as to why many people with obesity regain weight following successful weight loss."



    https://fitose.com/keto-burn-xtreme/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Slim Quick Keto So it is required to limit the intake of calories in the body. Here are some healthy tips and natural weight loss remedies that can help a person to burn fat in effective manner and provide perfect body shape.


    https://fitose.com/slim-quick-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nutrix Slim Keto : Then why not keep on the bed and breakfast lodges motels and resorts. Why do you ask?Thus taking this into account, to lose weight in the quickest time you wish to be performing exercises that moves over a series of joints and a collection of muscles, if not all of your muscles. It contains a compound referred to as allicin that has anti bacterial effects. Some studies denote that it may slightly increase the potential to burn calories and now will be found in several weight loss supplements.

    Visit Us : https://www.healthysuppreviews.com/nutrix-slim-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  12. by 19th century artist Canova (the Venere Italica), landscapes by 17th century creator Salvator Rosea, and cardinal activity by 16th century artist Titian (including La Bella, and Catholic Julius II's portrait). --- Author chemist (originally the palazzo's actress position, with mainly covered decorations), which is where temporary exhibitions are sometimes held. Stag APARTMENTS The stag apartments get 14 rooms that were erst old as living lodging for the Medicis and their successors. They now sanctuary portraits of Medici lineage members, umteen through by Giusto Sustermans. Most of the first furnishings in the apartments make been replaced, but a few of the newfangled pieces are allay movieshook

    ReplyDelete
  13. Buy12Pills Your frame can still manufacture carbohydrates from protein and one of the components of fat (glycerol). Ketones. Each organ except the brains and the fearful machine can use fatty acids as an alternative fuel supply. Sincerely the brains and the worried gadget can function pretty successfully without glucose (carbohydrates), because they are able to stand up to 75% of power from ketones.

    http://buy12pills.com/vita-slim-keto-diet/

    ReplyDelete

  14. Keto Weight Loss Plus There are many effective Health & Wellness Product of our Website.That has Made By Natural and effective Ingredients there is noone side effects. you can boost your stamina weight loss by this product.Just Grab It in limited time offers for New customers.

    For Many other information Click Here: http://www.ketoweightloss-plus.com/

    http://www.ketoweightloss-plus.com/organa-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  15. thanks… I’ve been bookmarking them for a while now and just decided to create scr888 free credit rm10 2019 a post to provide them to others…

    ReplyDelete
  16. In the event that you are uncertain which items are protected with condoms, VigRx Oil is an exceedingly esteemed and prescribed answer for attempt.

    male extra

    ReplyDelete
  17. Healthy sup Previews
    This Product Regular exercise and physical activity is the path to health and well-being. Exercise burns fat, builds muscle, lowers cholesterol, eases stress and anxiety, lets us Enjoy full day restfully.
    https://www.healthysuppreviews.com/
    https://www.healthysuppreviews.com/nuvo-ketosis/

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thenutritionsclinic Nobody knows without a doubt, yet it is a superb beginning. Along these lines, consider this in . "Spear Winslow" Online Think Tank gathering board. In the event that you have creative musings and novel points of view, come think with Lance; Heartburn is an ailment showed in an awkward sensation in the chest. This happens when corrosive returns up into an individual's throat.
    https://thenutritionsclinic.com/

    ReplyDelete
  19. Massive Male Plus These get permanent gains, due to the fact the erection is made of ligaments and tissues, now not muscle. After you get to the size you want, you simply stop and the profits stay, that is due to the fact once more, this is tissue. Do those penis physical games and you could get " large for lifestyles all the sports which you need to get a bigger penis for life. Loads of lots of fellows everywhere in the international are doing these and getting first rate outcomes. This is the remaining competitive advantage.
    https://thenutritionsclinic.com/massive-male-plus/

    ReplyDelete


  20. aboutthemcat
    ensure looks at! Be that as it may, they express this enhancement utilizes CLA, or United Linoleic Acid to uprise your body into the metabolic status of ketoshttp://healthonway.com/slim-quick-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Ultraskillpills Historical humans could be surprised if they resurrected to peer the forms of diseases that are troubling people these days. Specialists assert that lifestyle headaches like diabetes, high blood pressure, cardiovascular ailments and weight problems and answerable for extra deaths than conventional diseases like malaria and cholera to name a few. The importance of fitness and health may be understood when one considers the risk of mortality associated with being overweight or overweight.
    https://ultraskillpills.com/

    ReplyDelete
  22. ketogenicpedia Take as plenty relaxation as viable and don't do heavy guide obligations for the primary few days postsurgery. You could also notice tiny acne or cysts appearing in the recipient region. Those acne usually seem after a month of surgical procedure and disappear on their own after new hair starts growing.
    https://ketogenicpedia.com/

    ReplyDelete




  23. health and fitness wiki


    Welcome to the Health And Fitness Wiki, Buy the best health and fitness products for men's health workouts. We offer the best health and fitness products at affordable prices.



    https://healthandfitnesswiki.com/

    ReplyDelete
  24. Get latest current Healthy Eating Tips News and information for Healthier Families from the HealthifyPedia Team who shared the healthy lifestyle tips, solutions from different sources hope you love it keep stay tuned. https://healthifypedia.com/food/

    ReplyDelete

  25. Regardless, there isn't always most effective a unmarried Male Enhancement you could study and say this.

    i'll additionally throw in this relevant to this. I wouldn't keep to try this if Male Enhancement wasn't a laugh. i was inquisitive about their provide before everything. Categorically, at least I recognise that i'm reduce out for it.

    Read More- https://www.nutrahealthpro.com/magnum-xt/

    https://www.facebook.com/nutrahealthpro/posts/208407707665697

    https://twitter.com/nutrahealthpro/status/1352985357491564544

    https://nutrahealthpro1.blogspot.com/2020/08/magnum-xt-male-enhancement.html

    https://sites.google.com/view/magnum-xt-order-now/home

    https://in.pinterest.com/pin/596867756863616336

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQCU6w33JKc&feature=youtu.be

    https://www.instagram.com/p/CKZCO-Xlzbq/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you for taking the chance to talk about this, I'm strongly about this and really like having to learn more about this type of field. Do you mind updating your site article with extra insight? It ought to be really beneficial for every one of us.
    How To Get Free Robux

    ReplyDelete
  27. How to fix videos not uploading to Facebook?

    To fix videos not uploading to Facebook, try checking for an update. Outdated or obsolete versions of any software or application could pose performance and incompatibility issues on your device. For that, tap on Google Play Store to launch it. Now, tap on Menu to open the side menu. After this, tap on My Apps & Games. Lastly, tap on Update next to the Facebook app if an update is available.

    Also Read

    change facebook password on iphone
    how to turn off comments on facebook marketplace listing
    facebook unresponsive
    clear facebook search history
    how to recover permanently deleted facebook account
    how to disable facebook account
    how to lock your facebook profile
    how to bypass two-factor authentication facebook
    how to schedule facebook posts

    ReplyDelete